Rare Coin Market Report – May 22, 2025
The rare coin market remains healthy and active as we approach mid-2025, with values continuing to trend upward. Over the past year, prices have risen by roughly 20%, outpacing gold’s 10% annual increase. This growth is being driven by steady demand from both collectors and investors who are seeking reliable stores of value with historical and aesthetic appeal.
Key Price Movements
Collector favorites like Morgan and Peace Dollars are holding their ground in the market. According to recent NGC price data, circulated examples of the 1884 and 1885 Morgan Dollars are typically valued between $41 and $63. Meanwhile, the 1926 Peace Dollar, a staple among silver coin collectors, ranges in price from approximately $37.50 to $70 depending on condition.
Older American coinage also remains a key focus. For instance, the 1802 Draped Bust Dollar shows substantial value, with prices ranging from $1,100 to $17,000 in circulated condition. On the gold side, the 1855 Gold Dollar is currently trading between $300 and $1,000, reflecting consistent interest in pre-1933 U.S. gold coins.
The PCGS Rare Coin Market Report notes recent shifts in specific coins: the 1840-O No Drapery Quarter in MS65 condition has jumped nearly 30% in value, now listed at $55,000 (up from $42,500). Meanwhile, the 1838 Seated Liberty Quarter in MS64+ saw a modest drop, down about 9.5% from $21,000 to $19,000. These price movements underscore the importance of scarcity, grade, and certification in influencing collector value.
Greysheet’s May 2025 analysis reflects a market that, while leveling off from its recent surge, is still strong—particularly for coins with CAC endorsements or those in top condition. Even as some prices stabilize, premiums remain high for exceptional examples.
Precious Metals Market Impact
Precious metals continue to lend strength to the coin market. Gold is currently hovering near $3,250 per ounce—an all-time high—bolstered by strong central bank buying, inflation concerns, and global uncertainty. Silver has also performed well, trading just above $32.50 per ounce. These elevated spot prices enhance the appeal of bullion-based and numismatic coins alike.
Looking Ahead
As economic conditions remain uncertain, rare coins are becoming increasingly attractive as long-term tangible assets. Investors and collectors alike value the stability, beauty, and legacy these coins provide. With a fixed supply and growing interest—especially in high-grade and certified coins—the rare coin market is expected to remain resilient through the rest of the year.
Sources:
-
NGC Price Guide: www.ngccoin.com
-
PCGS Rare Coin Market Report: www.pcgs.com/rcmr
-
Greysheet Market Analysis – May 2025: www.greysheet.com
-
Universal Coin & Bullion Market Report: www.universalcoin.com
Disclaimer: The information provided in this report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Investors should conduct their own research or consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.
